
For laptops that handle company data every day, company-owned devices give IT more control over security, setup and replacement; BYOD gives employees choice but limits what IT can manage and can shift costs back to the company. You can also mix the two: NIST describes tiered access by device type [4].
How the two compare
| Company-owned | BYOD | |
|---|---|---|
| Management | Full device management. On Apple devices, Automated Device Enrollment supervises the device and allows all Apple-defined payloads and restrictions [1][2] | Limited. Apple's User Enrollment for BYOD lets IT manage only the organization's accounts, settings and data, never the user's personal account [3] |
| Access to company systems | NIST gives the example of organization-owned PCs accessing many resources [4] | NIST gives the example of BYOD PCs accessing a limited set, and BYOD phones and tablets one or two lower-risk resources such as webmail [4] |
| Network risk | Secured by the organization | NIST says BYOD devices are typically not secured to the same degree as the organization's own devices, and suggests a separate network for them [4] |
| Cost | Company buys, protects and replaces the laptop | Employee buys it, but some laws require reimbursement. California requires employers to reimburse expenses employees incur doing their jobs [5] |
| Protection and carry | Company can issue the same case and bag to everyone | Up to the employee |
| Offboarding | Laptop comes back | Company data must be removed from a personal device |
How to decide
- Classify your data. If staff handle sensitive data, NIST's tiered model points toward company-owned laptops for full access [4].
- Decide by role. Laptops for core work, BYOD for limited access such as email on personal phones.
- Check reimbursement rules where your employees work [5].
- Write it down. Put ownership rules in your company laptop policy.
Other approaches
Another route is a choice program, where employees pick from a short list of company-owned models. A stipend toward a personal laptop is a third route. Each changes who owns, protects and replaces the device.
FAQ
Is BYOD less secure than company-owned laptops?
NIST says BYOD devices are typically not secured to the same degree as an organization's own devices [4], so it suggests limiting their access and using a separate network.
Can IT see personal data on a BYOD Mac or iPhone?
With Apple's User Enrollment, IT can manage only the organization's accounts, settings and data, never the user's personal account [3].
Do employers have to pay for BYOD laptops?
It depends on where employees work. California requires employers to reimburse expenses employees incur doing their jobs [5].
Can a company mix BYOD and company-owned devices?
Yes. NIST describes tiered access by device type [4].
Related questions
- What should a company laptop policy include?
- Apple Business Manager vs MDM: what each one does
- Business Device Guide
Sources
- Apple Platform Deployment, "Automated Device Enrollment and device management". https://support.apple.com/guide/deployment/automated-device-enrollment-management-dep73069dd57/web
- Apple Platform Deployment, "Enrollment methods for Apple devices". https://support.apple.com/guide/deployment/enrollment-methods-for-apple-devices-dep08f54fcf6/web
- Apple Platform Deployment, "User Enrollment and device management". https://support.apple.com/guide/deployment/user-enrollment-and-device-management-dep23db2037d/web
- NIST, Special Publication 800-46 Rev. 2, "Guide to Enterprise Telework, Remote Access, and Bring Your Own Device (BYOD) Security" (Jul 2016). https://csrc.nist.gov/pubs/sp/800/46/r2/final
- California Department of Industrial Relations, Labor Commissioner's Office, "Deductions" (FAQ; Labor Code Section 2802 business expenses). https://www.dir.ca.gov/dlse/FAQ_Deductions.htm

